Book Review: Once Upon a Wardrobe by Patti Callahan

Patti Callahan's "Once Upon a Wardrobe" is more than just a piece of historical fiction; it is a profound meditation on the power of story itself. This book is a true inspiration, stirring an impulse to create and reminding readers that imagination can transform even deep tragedy into a narrative of heroism and overcoming obstacles.

Image Source: Amazon

The Mystery of Story and Inspiration

The central quest of the novel—young, frail George's dying request to know "Where did Narnia come from?"—sets up a beautiful exploration of literary creation. Callahan's portrayal of author C. S. Lewis ("Jack") is nuanced and warm. His response to George's question is not a simple fact, but a tapestry of life tales woven by Lewis and his brother, Warnie. These stories simultaneously do and don't answer the boy, suggesting that the origin of great tales is a profound and satisfying mystery.

I especially appreciated the novel's proposal that we gain more from asking the questions and embracing curiosity than from receiving easy, definitive answers. Each tale shared is like an echo of our own lives and the lives we wish to lead, reinforcing how stories connect the factual world to the mythical.

The Heart of the Novel: Relationships

The emotional anchor of the book lies in the deep and loyal relationships, particularly the dynamic between the protagonist, Megs Devonshire, and her younger brother, George. Megs, a woman of science, tries desperately to understand the magic of fairy tales for George, even as she feels she has outgrown them. This love compels her to seek out Lewis, making her journey a beautiful act of sibling devotion.

The book also incorporates a gentle, deep romance story that enriches Megs's journey. All of the relationships are portrayed with a deep loyalty that anchors the emotional stakes of the narrative.

Triumph Over Darkness

A key takeaway is the book's acknowledgment of life's necessary darkness. As noted, there must always be a "bad part" for the good to resonate so profoundly. This idea lends weight and sincerity to the novel's themes of hope and wonder, showcasing how the human spirit—and the imagination—can find light even in the shadow of impending loss.

Final Verdict

"Once Upon a Wardrobe" is not only a tribute to Narnia but a beautifully crafted novel in its own right. It is written in an engaging, lyrical language that is easy to read and exceptionally hard to put down. This is a must-read for anyone who has ever wondered about the magic behind their favorite stories.